*This post may contain affiliate links for which I earn commissions.*
When you were thinking about starting an online business, you likely ran into these questions almost immediately. . .
Should I build a website?
Start a YouTube channel?
Or just write a newsletter?
At first, it feels like a technical decision. It’s not. It’s a different beast altogether.
It’s really about comfort, confidence, and how you naturally prefer to communicate.
You need to pick ONE thing that is easy for you to start – and run consistently.
Most beginners get stuck here far longer than they should. Why?
Well, it’s certainly not because they lack ability. Rather, it’s because they’re trying to pick the “best” option instead of the easiest one for THEM to start and keep moving forward with.
Which is also why blindly following someone else’s successful path can be a disaster. What comes naturally for them and what they find easy to do may feel like pulling teeth for you.
As a result, your probability of failure goes up dramatically. Not good.
I’ll help you choose a starting point that fits you. Not what works for influencers or tech experts, but what works for someone balancing real life, responsibilities, and a desire to build something steady and meaningful.
1. Start With How You Naturally Communicate
Before thinking about platforms, think about yourself.
Think of how you express ideas most comfortably.
- Do you enjoy writing and explaining things in detail?
- Do you like speaking and sharing stories out loud?
- Do you prefer quick, simple communication without overthinking structure?
Your answers point you toward your best starting platform. (Below, I’ll show you how to decide in about 15 minutes.)
Here’s a simple way to look at it:
- If you like writing at your own pace
A website or newsletter will feel natural. - If you’re comfortable speaking and being seen
YouTube can work well, even with basic equipment. - If you want low pressure and simplicity
A newsletter is often the easiest place to begin.
Many people in their 40s and 50s assume they need to “learn video” because it’s popular. But forcing yourself into a format you dislike usually leads to burnout before results show up.
The goal isn’t to pick what’s trending. It’s not to do what your local online celebrity does for a living. The goal is to pick what you’ll stick with for the next 90 days.
If you’re still feeling unsure about how all of this fits into a bigger picture, a simple book like The 1-Page Marketing Plan by Allan Dib can help. It breaks down how to build a business step by step without complexity, which is especially useful when you’re just getting started.
2. Understand the Effort Behind Each Option
All three paths can work. But they require very different types of effort.
Website (Blog)
A website is like building a small digital asset over time.
Good for:
- People who like structured writing
- Those who want long-term traffic from search engines
- Anyone who prefers working quietly behind the scenes
Reality check:
- Takes time to see traffic
- Requires basic setup (domain, hosting, simple design)
Once it’s running, it becomes one of the most stable platforms you can own.
Incidentally, this is what I started with many moons ago. It’s still my preferred vehicle for online business building, along with email newsletters. And it’s working for me – after all, you’re reading this right? 🙂
YouTube
YouTube is powerful, but it comes with visibility.
Good for:
- People comfortable speaking or willing to learn
- Those who enjoy explaining things visually
- Anyone okay being on camera or using voiceovers
Reality check:
- Initial discomfort is normal
- Requires consistency and basic editing knowledge (the latter is not too difficult with today’s tools)
- Feedback is public, which can feel intimidating at first
That said, even simple talking videos can work. You don’t need a studio setup.
If you do want a small upgrade, a basic USB microphone like the Blue Snowball can noticeably improve your audio quality without adding complexity. But it’s entirely optional – your phone is more than enough to start off with.
Newsletter
A newsletter is the most underrated starting point.
Good for:
- People who want simplicity
- Those who don’t want to deal with websites or video yet
- Anyone who enjoys direct, one-to-one communication
Reality check:
- You need to actively grow your subscriber list
- No built-in traffic like YouTube or Google
But here’s the advantage: you can start writing and sending emails today. No complex setup required.
3. Choose Based on Your Current Season of Life
This is the part most advice skips.
You’re not just choosing a platform. You’re choosing something that fits into your life right now.
Ask yourself:
- How much time can I realistically commit each week?
- Do I have quiet, uninterrupted time to record videos?
- Do I prefer working early mornings, late nights, or in short bursts?
Here’s how that plays out:
- Busy schedule with limited energy
Start with a newsletter. It’s flexible and forgiving. - Steady routine with some quiet time
A website works well. You can build gradually. - More time and willingness to experiment
Try YouTube, even if it feels uncomfortable at first.
There’s no permanent decision here. Many successful creators start with one format and expand later.
The mistake is trying to do all three at once.
4. Pick One Lane and Reduce Friction
Once you choose, your next job is to make it as easy as possible to continue.
Remove unnecessary complications.
If you choose a website:
- Use a simple platform like WordPress or a beginner-friendly builder
- Start with 5 to 10 helpful articles, not perfection
- Focus on clarity, not design
If you choose YouTube:
- Use your phone camera
- Keep videos short and focused
- Don’t worry about editing too much in the beginning
A simple smartphone tripod can make recording easier and more comfortable, especially if you don’t want to hold your phone while talking
If you choose a newsletter:
- Write like you speak
- Keep emails simple and useful
- Send consistently, even if it’s once a week
Progress comes from repetition, not complexity.
How to Decide in 15 Minutes
If you’re still unsure, use this quick decision guide.
Step 1: Answer these honestly
- I prefer:
- Writing
- Speaking
- Simple communication without structure
- I feel comfortable being visible:
- Yes
- No
- I can commit:
- 2 to 3 hours per week
- 5+ hours per week
Step 2: Match your answers
- Writing + low visibility + limited time
→ Start with a newsletter - Writing + patience + long-term mindset
→ Start with a website - Speaking + okay with visibility + willing to learn
→ Start with YouTube
Step 3: Commit for 30 days
Pick one platform and stick with it for a full month.
No switching. No second-guessing.
At the end of 30 days, you’ll have more clarity than any amount of research can give you.
Simple tools to make it happen
If you decide to start with a newsletter, one tool that’s simple and beginner-friendly is AWeber.
It’s especially helpful if:
- You’re new to email marketing
- You want an easy setup without technical confusion
- You prefer straightforward tools over complex dashboards
It lets you create signup forms, send emails, and manage subscribers without feeling overwhelmed. That’s exactly what most beginners need.
For websites, a basic WordPress setup with reliable hosting is enough to get started. You don’t need premium themes or complicated plugins in the beginning.
For YouTube, your smartphone and natural lighting are more than enough.
Choosing between a website, YouTube, or a newsletter isn’t about picking the “best” platform.
It’s about picking the one you’ll actually use.
The simplest path is often the smartest one. Especially when you’re starting later in life, balancing responsibilities, and trying to build something meaningful without unnecessary stress.
Start where you feel comfortable. Build consistency. Let confidence grow naturally from action.
You can always expand later. What matters now is that you begin.
As they say, well begun is half-done. . .
Go ahead, make your choice today.